STARKE, Fla. (AP) - Scheduled to die Wednesday by
lethal injection for the 1976 stabbing death of a prison snitch,
Bennie Demps claimed he was innocent, framed because he had cheated
the executioner in a 1971 double murder.
"They are trying to execute me in this case for that case," Demps
said. "They want a free execution."
Unless his case is stayed, Demp is scheduled to die at 6 p.m. EDT
Wednesday at Florida State Prison, located nine miles from the small
city of Starke.
"I am an innocent man. I was wrongly convicted in the murder and
I should be allowed to prove it," Demps said.
Demps, 49, a Vietnam War veteran, was originally condemned for
the 1971 murders of R.N. Brinkworth and Celia Puhlick, who were
fatally shot in a Lake County citrus grove. The victims were
inspecting some land for sale when they happened upon Demps, who had
fled to the grove with a stolen safe.
A year after Demps was sent to death row, the U.S. Supreme Court
threw out capital punishment across the country, ruling death
sentences were unconstitutional.
Demps and 96 other death row inmates were taken off Florida's
death row.
In July 1976, the nation's high court upheld Florida's new
capital punishment law. Two months later, on Sept. 6, 1976, Alfred
Sturgis was fatally stabbed in his prison cell.
Before he died, Sturgis reportedly told a guard that Demps and
another inmate had held him down while a third stabbed him. In 1978,
Demps was sentenced to death.
The huskily built former Marine, who was wounded in Vietnam,
claimed the dying words of inmate Sturgis and alleged eyewitness
testimony from another inmate were both fabricated.
"I always knew that these people fabricated the evidence against
me," said Demps, wearing the orange shirt which identifies death row
inmates and a white knit cap because he is Muslim.
Demps said he was not involved in Sturgis' death. He claims he
was in the shower at the time of the slaying.
"I am seeking justice in this case," Demps said. "I was wrongly
convicted in a murder."
In a 1981 ruling affirming Demps' sentence, the Florida Supreme
Court said Demps' previous conviction was a factor in his death
sentence. The court rejected an argument that it should be
overturned because the other two inmates, James Jackson and Harry
Mungin, were given life sentences. Both are still incarcerated.
Only Demps had the "loathsome distinction of having been
previously convicted of the first-degree murder of two persons and
attempted murder of another, escaping the gallows only through the
intervention of Furman v. Georgia," the high court wrote in its
unsigned decision, citing the 1972 decision that vacated death
sentences across the country.
Demps pointed to a newly discovered document written the day
after the Sturgis slaying which lists Jackson as the assailant and
does not mention Demps.
Since his second death sentence, Demps has survived death
warrants in 1982, 1987, and 1990 by winning last-minute appeals.
Demps had appeals pending Tuesday in the 11th U.S. Circuit Court
of Appeals in Atlanta and the U.S. Supreme Court - both were
longshots.
Also Tuesday the Florida Supreme Court did not delay the
execution, refusing to give Demps more time to pursue federal
appeals.
Demps is the third inmate scheduled to be executed this year and
will be the third to be put to death by lethal injection. He will be
the first inmate executed for killing another inmate. Since Florida
resumed the death penalty, 46 inmates have been put to death.
Another inmate, Thomas Provenzano, 50, is scheduled to die June 20.
Demps said he was hoping for a last-minute miracle to save his
life.
"No man is ready to die."
AP-ES-06-06-00 2023EDT