SUPREME COURT OF FLORIDA
BENNIE DEMPS, CASE NO.: SC00-1118
Appellant, Lower Tribunal No.: 77-0116-CFA
vs.
STATE OF FLORIDA,
Appellee.
/
MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE PENDING
PETITION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS
The appellant, Bennie Demps, through the undersigned court-appointed
appellate counsel, George F. Schaefer, moves this court for an order consolidating
the petition for writ of mandamus filed this date by the petitioner in this court, a
copy of which is attached and which includes the case number for the mandamus
action. The following grounds support this motion:
1. In the case at hand, the appellant is appealing the trial court's denial of
his fourth postconviction relief motion in which petitioner seeks to vacate his first
degree murder conviction and death sentence.
2. On May 27, 2000 this court stayed the pending death warrant issued
by Governor Jeb Bush until 5:00 p.m. on June 7, 2000.
2
3. The pending petition for writ of mandamus filed by Mr. Demps asserts
that Governor Jeb Bush and Attorney General Robert Butterworth violated the
scheduling and notice requirements regarding executions following a stay found at
§§922.052 and 922.06, Fla. Stat.
4. The relief requested in the petition for writ of mandamus is factually
intertwined with the substantive and procedural facts in the case at hand which
makes the consolidation of the two cases appropriate.
A. MEMORANDUM OF LAW
In State v. Fourth District Court of Appeal, 697 So.2d 70 (Fla. 1997) this
court acknowledged that collateral proceedings in death penalty cases are
essentially an attack on imposition of the death penalty. This court then went on to
hold that in addition to appellate jurisdiction over death sentences, this court has
exclusive jurisdiction to review all types of collateral proceedings in death penalty
cases. In the case at hand, Mr. Demps seeks reversal of the trial court's denial of
postconviction relief and in the petition for writ of mandamus, Mr. Demps is
seeking to force the respondents (Governor Jeb Bush and Attorney General Robert
Butterworth) to comply with the scheduling and notice requirements under Florida
law for executions. In the former matter this court has appellate jurisdiction and in
3
the latter matter this court has original jurisdiction. Because the two actions are
factually and legally interrelated, they should be consolidated.
DATED this 4
th day of June, 2000.George F. Schaefer
The Liberty House
1005 S.W. Second Avenue
Gainesville, Florida 32601-6116
(352) 338-1111
Florida Bar No.: 308870
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that a true and correct copy of the foregoing pleading was
furnished by hand delivery to Curtis French, Assistant Attorney General, The
Capitol, Suite PL-01, Tallahassee, Florida 32399-1050 and U.S. mail delivery to
Gregory McMahon, Assistant State Attorney, P.O. Box 1437, Gainesville, Florida
32602 on this 4
th day of June, 2000.George F. Schaefer
The Liberty House
1005 S.W. Second Avenue
Gainesville, Florida 32601-6116
(352) 338-1111
4
Florida Bar No.: 308870